lee_jianguo | 1 points | Aug 16 2021 19:05:34

退役美国海军上将James G. Stavridis:阿富汗军队从最开始就是注定失败的。

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-08-16/the-afghan-army-was-always-doomed

退役美国海军上将James G. Stavridis在Bloomberg上发表的评论文章。方便没有订阅的浪人,这里节选一部分内容:

"... the effort failed in many separate aspects. First comes the lack of will and leadership on the part of the Afghan government and people. "

" In retrospect, we trained the wrong kind of army for Afghanistan. "

" We should have emphasized what might be called “Afghan-right” fighters, meaning forces that were far lighter, and could fight in decentralized teams, squads, light platoons and quick-maneuver companies."

" the Afghans should have been organized into local, light-defense forces in and around their own villages, districts and provinces. People will fight much harder when it is their own family behind them."

" ' We gave them everything they needed, and they failed.'... Americans also need to admit that we built that failed army, over the course of 15 years."

[-] lee_jianguo | 9 points | Aug 16 2021 19:13:43

顺便,"the Afghans should have been organized into local, light-defense forces in and around their own villages, districts and provinces. People will fight much harder when it is their own family behind them." 这条感觉像是阿姨会提出的方案。

[-] DirectIndividual4621 | 7 points | Aug 16 2021 20:16:29

呵呵,绿畜马上军阀混战给你看

[-] eleewave | 6 points | Aug 16 2021 19:38:47

搭便車搭的太習慣了

[-] 1991li | 4 points | Aug 16 2021 19:54:50

同气相求、守望相助,曾胡以此平洪杨之乱

[-] Background_Act_6563 | 8 points | Aug 16 2021 20:21:59

人民選擇了中世紀的生活方式

[-] F_Silence | 8 points | Aug 16 2021 22:43:57

美国去阿富汗剿基地抓拉登是没错的,世贸大楼总不能被白撞,但是2011年完成任务就应该直接走人,这10年净剩下军火商瓜分税款了。

[-] Beneficial_Book1783 | 1 points | Aug 17 2021 10:57:52

翻译一下就是民团。